Home / Pattern reviews

✂Honest reviews✿Same scorecard

Pattern Reviews

Rate it like a product designer. Five scores, out of 25. Every review uses the same criteria, so you can compare patterns side by side before you buy.

The scorecard

How every pattern is scored

Each criterion gets a score from 1 (meh) to 5 (love).

1.

Instructions

Could a confident beginner follow them? Clear order, good illustrations, and real help at the tricky bits: collars, zips, plackets.

12345
2.

Drafting & fit

Do pieces line up and notches match? Does the finished garment look like the photos on a real body?

12345
3.

Size range

How many bodies does it serve? Multiple cup sizes? More than one body type in the samples?

12345
4.

Printing & assembly

Layers? Copy-shop (A0) and projector files? How painful was the taping?

12345
5.

Value

Price compared to views, how often you’ll make it again, and the support behind it.

12345
TOTAL SCORE/25
21–25

Buy it

Recommend it to anyone at the right skill level.

16–20

Good, with caveats

Worth it if the caveats don’t apply to you.

11–15

Proceed with care

Expect to fix things.

10 & under

Skip it

Or wait for a revised version.

Every review also includes

  • Pattern
  • Designer
  • Garment
  • Date sewn
  • Size made
  • Fabric
  • Price paid
  • Format
  • Fit changes I made

Would I make it again?

  • Yes, already planning it
  • Maybe, with changes
  • No, once was enough

The reviews

Latest reviews